This , That or another Ice Cream flavor. ------Chocolate, Vanilla , or another

[debm55]

Last edited Thu Mar 26, 2026, 10:30 AM - Edit history (1)

[FalloutShelter]

1. Butter Pecan

[debm55]

3. Thank you very much, FalloutShelter.

[MIButterfly]

2. Chocolate, chocolate and more chocolate!

Only 10 more days until the end of Lent!

[debm55]

4. hahahahahah Thank you very much, MIButterfly.

[MIButterfly]

9. When I first responded, I don't think it said ice cream,

just Chocolate, Vanilla or Other. With it being flavors of ice cream, I have to change my answer to Cherry Garcia, with Stephen Colbert's Americone Dream a close second. But I'd still have to wait until Easter to eat either one because they both have chocolate in them.

I do love me some Ben & Jerry's.

[debm55]

10. It didn't , but people were putting ice cream flavors. I go with the flow and edited the OP to show ice cream. Sorry for

the confusion.

[MIButterfly]

11. No worries! It's all good.

[Morbius]

60. I too gave up chocolate for lent.

I am looking forward to cookies containing chocolate come Easter. I miss that more than anything else.

Ice cream? I love pumpkin ice cream, but it's hard to find in season and impossible at this time of the year.

[cloudbase]

5. Peach.

Especially the stuff from the Chocolate Shoppe in Wisconsin.

(RIP Isaly's)

[debm55]

6. Thank you, cloudbase. Yes, Isaly's had the best ice cream.

[lark]

7. cookie dough

Chocolate chip cookie dough to be specific
Anything with both chocolate and carmel, especially if it has pecans too.

[debm55]

8. Thank you very much, lark

[Mad_Dem_X]

12. Chocolate Chip!

[debm55]

13. Yum. Thank you for your flavor. Mad_Dem_X Enjoy.

[CTyankee]

14. I adore so many flavors of ice cream and the list is endless (or so it seems)

especially ice cream atop Black Forest cherry pie.

[debm55]

16. Wonderful, CTyankee. Thank you and enjoy.

[Coventina]

15. Mint chocolate chip!!!

[debm55]

17. Yummy. Thank you , Coventina for sharing and enjoy.

[johnp3907]

18. My homemade Stracciatella!

😋

[debm55]

19. Thank you very much for sharing. johnp3907. Enjoy.

[lucca18]

20. Coffee Ice Cream!❤️

But, I do love chocolate ice cream too!😍

[debm55]

21. Thank you very much for sharing your selection, lucca18 Enjoy

[applegrove]

22. Spumoni!!! My grandmother used to serve that to us

in the 60s and 70s.

[debm55]

25. Love it too. Thank you for sharing your selection, applegrove and enjoy.

[Vinca]

23. My current favorite is Tillamook's sugar cookie flavor. I'm addicted to Tillamook!

[debm55]

26. Thank you for sharing with us, Vinca. Enjoy.

[TommieMommy]

24. Coffee ice cream is my favorite 😁

[debm55]

27. Thank you very much, TommieMommy. Enjoy.

[GentryDixon]

28. Tillamook Coffee Almond Fudge 😋

[debm55]

30. Wonderful and thank you GentryDixon. Enjoy.

[CTyankee]

35. Tillimook ice cream is the BEST. I have 2 big cartons in my freezer now:

Oregon Dark Cherry and Chocolate Peanut butter. I plan to get more ASAP. My daughter orders it for me but she is in Europe on a trip and I'm gonna run out. WAH!!

[Mz Pip]

29. Caramel swirl

Anything swirly for me.

[debm55]

31. Thank you Mz Pip. That sounds wonderful. Enjoy.

[Ilikepurple]

32. I found can't tolerate dairy, but my memory says Vanilla Swiss almond.

Or peanut butter chocolate, or tahini swirl, or vanilla, or cookie dough, or cookies and cream. I’m just happy we have plenty of plant based options in my city, even if I can’t find all my former favorites. There’s probably not a trea5 I like more than a decent ice cream or ice cream like substance.

[debm55]

33. I am glad you have plant based ice creams, Love your selections, Ilikepurple. enjoy.

[Keepthesoulalive]

34. Creamsicle

Mixture of sherbet and vanilla.

[debm55]

43. Thank you very much, Keepthesoulalive. That sounds terrific. Enjoy.

[WmChris]

36. Whiteys

Moose Trax!

[debm55]

44. Thank you very much. WmChris. for sharing. Enjoy.

[C_U_L8R]

37. Jeni's Darkest Chocolate.

Food of the gods.

[debm55]

50. Oh wow. that sounds delicious. Thank you, C_U_L8R, for sharing .

[electric_blue68]

57. Oooooo!

😄

[Wiz Imp]

38. My favorite ice cream of all time is Chocolate Chip from a shop called the Yum Yum Tree in the Logan Valley Mall

It's no longer there. I have no idea when it closed. But I've never been able to find chocolate chip ice cream anywhere else nearly as good as that.

[debm55]

49. Thank you very much Wiz Imp, for your selection, Logan Valley Mall in Altoona,,,,,,,,,,Used to go there.

[Ritabert]

39. Oregon Dark Cherry from Tillamook.

[debm55]

48. Thank you very much for sharing with us. Ritabert. That sounds wounderful, Enjoy.

[3catwoman3]

40. Cold Stone Creamery's cake batter flavor...

...with mini M&Ms added in. M&Mmmmmmmm!

[debm55]

47. Thank you very much for sharing with us, 3catwoman3. that sounds so good. Enjoy.

[PufPuf23]

41. Today Ben and Jerry's Mousse Pie which is various forms of chocolate.

Bought when went out earlier today.

Have always loved ice cream but should not eat often or much now as diabetic II.

But have a broken tooth that subsequently lost an old filling and became infected.

My dental care in recent years has been Indian Health Service and even that is a 50 mile drive.

The Tribe has a nearly brand new 6 bay dentist building but no dentist. They have hired several that did not last. One took out a damaged molar and managed to damage the adjacent tooth and ended up losing three teeth on the one side. Went through chemo for lymphoma and was hard on my teeth and body in general.

Was just at the adjacent to new dental building for IHS doctor office Monday The doctor told me that the dentist was back, but he didn't realize that the most recent dentist had already come and gone, why I had not yet gotten any help for the tooth. That doctor was new and is also already leaving. Too remote for his wife and too many locals are not that friendly to blacks.

Any doctors or dentists looking for a job? Drop me a PM. Please.

In the meantime, I have an excuse to eat ice cream because I cannot chew

When I was a child (until 1964 when destroyed by a major flood), my family owned one of two local stores (only one now) and there was a lunch counter with great Humboldt Creamery ice cream. Now one needs to drive 85 miles to get fresh sit down ice cream.

In the East SF Bay Area, there was Fenton's (still exists) and Berkeley Farms ("farms in Berkeley?" people used to say, we had milk delivery at a home in Danville from Berkeley Farms and we went to the Berkeley Farms Creamery in Walnut Creek for a treat).

I love ice cream, favorite is cherry with chocolate.

[debm55]

46. Thank you very much, PufPuf23. I am sorry about your situation without a dentist. Enjoy your ice cream.

[bobalew]

42. Ben & Jerry's

Cherry Garcia AKA Deadhead Delight...

[debm55]

45. HAHAHAH. Thank you very much for sharing, bobalew. Enjoy.

[doc03]

51. Capachino crunch.

[debm55]

52. OHHHH. That sounds so great. Than you doc03 for sharing and enjoy.

[underpants]

53. Oyster

The only historical source for oyster ice cream is found in Mary Randolph's cookbook, The Virginia House-Wife, published in 1824.[1]


Contrary to various news reports in the 21st century, oyster ice cream was not served at the First Thanksgiving, nor was it a favorite of George Washington's, nor served in the White House by Dolley Madison, nor mentioned by Mark Twain in his novel The Adventures of Tom Sawyer.[3] However,
President James Madison's wife, first lady Dolley Madison, is reported to have served several different flavors of ice cream, both sweet and savory, including: asparagus, parmesan and oyster.[

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oyster_ice_cream

[debm55]

54. I'll pass on those flavors. Thank you underpants for sharing that information with usl.

[fargone]

55. Orange custard chocolate chip, Babcock dairy store

Univ Wisconsin, Madison. Add some hot fudge.

[debm55]

56. Yummy, Thank you very much for sharing, fargone.

[soldierant]

58. Kroger hs a line of flavors which only come in pints which tenf to be very good

Unfortunately, every time I get hooked on one it tends to get discontinues. Thar happened with Chocolate Mascarpone years ago, and then a few years later with Matcha Green Tea, and appears to be happening again with Mexican Hot Chocolate and maybe (I hope not) with Pistachio Honey. and Brown Butter Bourbon.

[electric_blue68]

59. C H O C O L A T E ! ! !

The best I've had is actually a Gelato.
Talenti Double Chocolate w vermouth.
Vermouth's a bit too sweet for me, but it's minimal enough to ignore it
The chocolate could be a dark type. Then they add these tiny irregular shaped "shards" of dark chocolate "chips".
Oh my goodness; soooo good!
😄 🥰 🥄
I'm actually hoping to get to the particular grocery Sun or Mon to get a pint! Not had in nearly a year? If they don't l have it; also make black raspberry gelato with the same dark chocolate shards. I like raspberry, and the shards are so good - quite an acceptable substitute.

Then Ben & Jerry's Chocolate Therapy (chocolate cream, chocolate cookies, and chocolate pudding ice cream); New York Super Fudge Chunk (chocolate ice cream, little "bars" of white [i pick those .out] & dark chocolate, walnuts, chocolate covered almonds); Chocolate Fudge Brownie (chocolate ice cream w brownie pieces still from Greystone Bakery in Yonkers. NY).
YUMMMS the word!

For Non-chocolate - Butter Pecan.