American History
Related: About this forumI have started reading Nigel Hamilton's trilogy on FDR as Commander in Chief during the Second World War.
The first book in the trilogy is FDR at War 1941-1942, "The Mantle of Command."
I must say that it is a pleasure to read. In the Prolog, Hamilton, a naturalized American of British origins, remarks - and I think this is a valid observation based on my experience - that while many authors have written on the military sense of Abraham Lincoln as "Commander in Chief," very few of Roosevelt's biographers do the same.
It is, thus far, a magnificent read, showing how FDR managed the war with great brilliance and intelligence, putting people like Winston Churchill and Douglas MacArthur in their place without them understand that they were being charmed into compliance unless a heavy hand was demanded, which it sometimes was. FDR used both Churchill and MacArthur not because they were wise military leaders - they were not - but as tools of the nebulous "spirit" of the war.
As a British born writer, I am very much impressed with his convincing realistic assessment of Churchill, the Imperialist and fabulist, who did, for all his faults, have his "finest hour" at the beginning of the war.
I am now at the part where Colonel Eisenhower - who had served with MacArthur as his subordinate and who despised him - began his rise to become the great political general he would become.
I have just read the part where Roosevelt bucks up President Quezon of the Philippines to convince him not to negotiate a surrender to the Japanese.
It is insightful writing. I love history books that cause one to "think anew." This is one of them.

Irish_Dem
(68,868 posts)So the British author did not see Churchill on the same level or caliber as FDR?
NNadir
(35,669 posts)...the United States entered it.
Irish_Dem
(68,868 posts)When Japan bombed Pearl Harbor Churchill knew Hitler would be defeated.
And UK saved from invasion.
bucolic_frolic
(50,021 posts)James McGregor Burns tackled FDR at war about 1971. Roosevelt: The Soldier of Freedom 1940-1945"
I've also read:
Franklin D. Roosevelt: A Political Life - Robert Dallek, 2017
FDR at War Trilogy - Nigel Hamilton, 2014, 2016, 2019
The Mantle of Command: FDR at War, 1941-1942
Commander in Chief: FDR's Battle with Churchill, 1943
War and Peace: FDR's Final Odyssey, D-Day to Yalta, 1943-1945
FDR - Jean Edward Smith, 2007
Eisenhower in War and Peace - Jean Edward Smith, 2012
All highly recommended. Dallek's is pure politics and fantastic, but I can't say any of them are anything less. Smith's is the easiest read, he is known for obscure and interesting material. There have of course been many others including Republican attempts to discredit.
NNadir
(35,669 posts)I've been to Springwood (New Hyde Park) twice, with my wife, the second time to attend a seminar on the Four Freedoms speech. The first was to see an exhibit on the decision to seek a fourth term. From that exhibit one could learn that his doctors certainly didn't expect him to survive it. His medical records were displayed when I was there, including some writings of his daughter Anna on his health. He was clearly in heart failure with blood pressure through the roof. (They had a video of the Fala speech, where he overcame his illness to appear vital.) This has always led me to wonder about the selection of Truman to displace Wallace. It proved to be an inspired choice, but certainly not an obvious one to anyone living at the time.
One comes away from touring the museum with a sense of FDRs domestic policy as preeminent. The war is there, of course but it's not at the forefront of the displays. Mostly it focuses on the New Deal.
Thanks for the suggested reading list. I doubt I'll get to all of it, but I have placed the full trilogy in my reading time budget, which is very stretched.
mobeau69
(11,943 posts)mike_c
(36,541 posts)I'm in the middle of Shirer. My main interest is in the cold war, but I figured I'd work my way through the whole 20th century to better understand it's origins. I was born in 1955 so much of the century was a blank page for me. I keep being drawn back into the world wars. Gawd the twentieth century was violent!
SheltieLover
(67,038 posts)I love FDR & always saw Joe as a modern day FDR, or as close to one as we could get.